Friday, October 30, 2026

Two decades of independent consulting: A reflection


This month I completed two decades of independent consulting. When I left my job in September 2006, I was almost 37 years old. I had a decade of work experience, but I was uncertain of my offerings, unsure of my unique skills, and doubtful of my ability to make money. My primary source of encouragement was Gauri, my wife, who was a school teacher then, and the school had generously waived fees for our son, who was then in primary. My father did not discourage me, but he felt I wasn’t cut out to run a business. And he was right in being skeptical. I was quiet, an introvert, not street-smart, more of a rule-follower, and not ambitious about making money. How was the journey so far? And what has been my learning from this journey?

Did you meet your financial goals? This question comes in different varieties. For example, some people ask, "Would you have made more money if you had continued working? I really admire our ability to do counterfactual thinking. When Bill Gates gave $800 to purchase a nuclear power plant simulator from Oak Ridge National Laboratory in 2005, his plan was to simulate thousands of worst-case scenarios like earthquakes, tsunamis, etc., to make sure the nuclear plant is safe. I didn’t run any such “what-if” scenarios, and I didn’t set any financial goals. I was planning to do my best to earn enough to pay the bills and hopefully to save some for the rainy days. As I wrote in the blog “Story of plan B” in 2008, I had spent ten years working (2 years in the US and 8 years in India), and the employee phase was a very satisfying and productive phase of my life. But after a decade, I felt that the phase was over. And I was willing to put all my energy into trying to make the new phase work. I started blogging in December 2007, thanks to nudges from friends Ravi Aranke and Ramprasad Moudgalya (RamP). I wrote 56 blogs in 2008 and 83 in 2009. That means I had more energy, more time, and less work in those initial years. I think I got really lucky, and despite my effort, it could have easily not worked out. During the last two decades, I made significantly more money than the bills. But that reflects more on the size of the bills than the money made. I use a 15-year-old bicycle (Hercules), a 15-year-old Maruti Estilo (renewed the registration a couple of months ago), and I have been debt-free for the past 15 years. Thanks to Buffett, Munger, and Buffett’s guru Benjamin Graham, margin of safety got ingrained pretty early in this period, and later also became an important step of the 8-steps to innovation framework.

It was passion, wasn’t it? I decided to quit my job in 2005, a year before I actually quit. By then I had been a sceptic of the notion of progress for a decade. In contrast, the corporate world was fueled by personal and professional progress, expressed in the form of revenue/profit growth, valuation, net worth, career progression, etc. Not being a sucker for the corporate value system, or for that matter, any organized value system, be it social, religious, or political, was the primary motivation to leave my job. I was clueless about what to do as an independent consultant, let alone be passionate about something. But I still had to answer: where to focus my energy and what to offer?

A few areas were ruled out after mixed success – project management, knowledge management, and competency framework development. I realized that my exposure to R&D management in the US and in India was a strength, and I could relate to moving up the value chain easily. Thanks to Hari Iyer at Sasken (my ex-employer), I got initial projects on developing technical leadership, and thanks to Thiagarajan (Tiger) and Poovannan (Poo) at ADP, Hyderabad, I got an assignment on fostering a culture of technical excellence. Both these engagements lasted multiple years and provided a solid base. From these engagements, I realized I enjoyed building innovation stamina (capacity) the most. Conferences like India Innovation Summit, forums like Bangalore Innovation Forum, and products like Tata Nano created excitement and gave access to success and failure stories from a close distance. This led to the collaboration with Prof. Rishikesha Krishnan, eventually leading to the 8-steps to innovation book.

Why independent consulting? Why not a team? Any team brings with it a set of aspirations. A startup is not only building a product or a service and serving a set of customers, but is also fulfilling dreams of families associated with the employees. I felt that my experimentation with progress-as-a-questionable entity would not work in a team setting. I was fortunate to get advice from veteran independent consultants like Arun Joshi-kaka, Raja Chidambaram, and V N Bhattacharya. I also did the next best thing: read books. Ricardo Semler’s Seven-day weekend became a source of inspiration, and it continues to inspire two decades later. Alan Weiss’s books on value-based consulting were companions for the initial period. However, without the trust and sponsorship from people like Hari Iyer, Tiger-Poo, Naresh Tyagi, Zunder Lekshmanan, and Vijay Anand in the initial years, things wouldn’t have moved.

Of course, work is more fun with collaborators. And I got to work with a ton of them.  Collaboration with Rishi on innovation management and with Prof Ganesh Prabhu on Design Thinking lasted several years. Working with a diverse set of people like Pradeep Desai, Ramesh S, Gaurav Kataria, Raja Chidambaram, S Yegneshwar, Raghu Kolli, Prof Anand Kusre, K Ganesh, Madhav Manthri, Akkiraju, Deepa C, S Rajasekaran, and many more made the journey enjoyable. Long walks with Jaykumar, Swami Krishnan, RamP, and Zunder, and chai sessions with Sanjeev Krishnan have been very helpful. 

Why Catalign Innovation Consulting? What kind of consulting should I do? Should I do some specialized work like a designer, a scientist, a programmer, or an accountant? Should I do a document as a deliverable, like a research report or a strategy recommendation for management? Should I drive a change initiative inside an organization? I didn’t do any of this, mostly. I became a fan of Edgar Schein’s process consulting approach, which he later called humble consulting, and decided that I would be a catalyst. I believed that, for an intervention to work, it has to be based on the organization’s strengths (bright spots), be culture-friendly, need a simple dashboard, and be championed from within. I facilitated workshops, asked questions, co-created dashboards, pointed to the internal bright spots, suggested process tweaks, and co-led challenge campaigns. However, in our innovation council meetings, a lot of good ideas came from other members. All I had to do was champion them, be it creating a virtual lab, running a campaign, or building a sandbox. Hence, a catalyst in alignment and innovation – Catalign Innovation Consulting turned out to be an apt banner. Initially, I thought the alignment would be to a given strategy; later I realized my work involves aligning to changing market forces and changing capability dynamics. I remember an ophthalmologist and an eye-hospital leader came to me after a workshop in Raipur and said, “I can do this exercise myself in my hospital.”

Thanks to Akki calling the workshops Innovathons, the metaphor of innovation stamina emerged. It means the capacity to solve complex challenges, preparedness to respond to forces of creative destruction, to borrow Schumpeter’s language. For most of my engagements “Moving Up The Value Chain” was a common aspiration. “Invest in preparedness, not prediction,” I latched on to Nassim Taleb’s Antifragility wisdom.

My collaborator S Ramesh gave me a mini-sermon quite early, saying that teaching would be complementary to consulting activity. It took me a couple of years to get convinced. He was right, teaching nudged me to learn new topics, to apply the frameworks to new situations, and learn from the students. Prof Ganapathy Lakshman (Jain University), Prof Satyajit Majumdar (TISS), and Swami Krishnan (IFIM) provided the initial teaching opportunities. Later, IIM Bangalore, thanks to Rishi, and IIT Bombay, thanks to Prof Kusre and Prof Milind Atrey, became my teaching platforms, and I am grateful to these institutions. However, in my mind, I am a consultant first, and teacher next.

How did I turn to design thinking and mindfulness? Prof Satyajit Majumdar invited me to TISS in 2011 to conduct workshops for his students of the Master of Social Entrepreneurship before they embarked on their month-long field visits. That is how design thinking workshops started. Prof Ganesh Prabhu and I did design thinking programs at IIM Bangalore for almost a decade. Thanks to Ajith Basu, I got an opportunity to influence the Innovation Hub program in Agastya's Kuppam campus and introduce design thinking to high school students. Given how poor we are at designing the citizenship revision SIR process, and at managing crowds in public spaces, especially around temples, I am convinced design thinking carries a lot of potential.

My friend Zunder Lekshmanan, who was then the CTO of Mahindra Comviva, suggested that I conduct a mindfulness workshop for his team. That was in 2015. I was hesitant. By then, I had spent two decades experimenting in that domain. But I was not associated with any tradition, religious or otherwise. The workshop was appreciated, and I decided to offer it to the public. I consciously decided not to market it to the corporate world. Mindfulness is learning to see that the process of becoming is an illusion. On what basis do I guarantee that employees will become more productive and profits will increase after insights like these? Some of them might leave their jobs. I do run the workshop at home once a quarter, and a few sessions happen at IIMB’s executive education, thanks to encouragement from Prof. Vasanthi Srinivasan.

Way forward? How do I see my next decade? As I mentioned, I am a fan of preparedness, not prediction. However, there are always a few ideas in the air; with luck, one or two click; most don’t. I have been fascinated by strategy as a subject lately. It began as a matter of curiosity when our son spent the past five years in Israel. Why do countries fight so much? How come a country like Israel, with world-class intelligence machinery, is fooled on the same day twice after fifty years? How come a country like Iran can fight the mighty US? How is Saudi with more than 20 times the defense budget of Houthis is struggling with low-cost drone attacks? I am curious, and it is likely to influence my work on strategic innovation, especially on the capacity to respond to creative destruction.

When I look at India’s innovation ecosystem radar after two decades, I see that a lot has changed, and a lot that needs to be done. Particularly, the lack of capacity for deep tech innovation is striking. I wrote last year that India woke up in 2025 while China could confidently say, “We have been preparing for the trade war for a decade.” I am curious about what is enabling deep tech innovation in India.

Thanks to Prof. Mukta Kulkarni, I will be teaching a Critical Thinking course at IIM Bangalore’s undergraduate program next semester. It will cover three forms of reasoning (deductive, inductive, and abductive), cognitive biases, and metacognition (awareness of the thinking process). It will also briefly introduce two critical thinkers of ancient India, Dignaga (5th Century) and Nagarjuna (2nd Century). Will critical thinking gain currency in the next few years? Who knows? But given the level of thinking demonstrated by various world leaders today, I won’t be surprised if it does.

Journey-centric mindfulness suggests that the journey is more important than the destination. How much has it sunk into my brain, blood, and bones? I don’t know.

India’s Innovation ecosystem: a framework and a visual dashboard of 2007 and 2026

I first came across a visual dashboard of the innovation ecosystem in India in 2008 when I read “NASSCOM-BCGInnovation Report 2007: Unleashing the innovative power of IT-ITES industry” (NB2007)[1]. The report presented the innovation ecosystem across various regions and countries such as Singapore, Israel, Germany (Bavaria), Eureka, Taiwan, and Silicon Valley. It mentioned that the Indian innovation ecosystem was at that time “weak on multiple dimensions.” It fit my image of simple dashboards like a weighing scale that would be useful in deciding courses of action. In 2008, I mentioned the dashboard in my blog and observed that “things aren’t that gloomy and the lead indicators look good at this point.” Indian innovation ecosystem has come a long way in the last two decades. However, in deep-tech and science-based innovations, the ecosystem is in its infancy. This became evident during the trade war last year. How does the innovation ecosystem dashboard in India look right now in 2026? That is what I would like to explore in this blog. 


Image source: NB2007, page 15 [1] 

2007 India innovation ecosystem dashboard: NB2007 presented the following radar view of the innovation ecosystems of 8 countries/regions. It has five dimensions: Government (G), Industry Bodies (IB), Firms (F), Education, Research & Development (E-R&D), Investors ($). The report highlighted that the degree of participation of the different constituents and the nature and strength of their interactions give the ecosystem its vibrancy and existential support. Some ecosystems, like Cube (biotech), were overly dependent on one dimension, such as Government. In contrast, the innovation ecosystems of Eureka (consortium), Taiwan, and Silicon Valley had all players playing a significant role in their interactions. Indian innovation ecosystem was weak due to insufficient participation by the constituents and also weak or negligible interaction between them. Both Israel and Taiwan began with one dominant player – the government. But over the years, other constituents and their interactions were strengthened.

Modifying the dimensions: Startups play a unique role in fostering an innovation ecosystem. Hence, it makes sense to add it as a separate dimension rather than clubbing them with established firms. So, let’s separate Established Firms (EF) and Startups (S) as different dimensions. Incubators and accelerators play an important role in connecting startups with investors, mentors, labs, and established firms. So, let’s enhance the scope of the Industry Bodies (IB) dimension to include these intermediaries. So IB includes Industry Bodies and Incubators. Before we can redraw India’s 2007 ecosystem radar with 6 dimensions, let’s define the rating scale.

Defining the ratings: NB2007 doesn’t present what the rating scale means. If this were to be a useful framework, it needs to elaborate on what 1 to 4 means on each dimension.

 

Dimension

1 - weak/isolated

2 – emerging / functional

3 - strong/capable

4 – world-class / self-reinforcing

Government (G)

Little meaningful support; policy/regulation may constrain innovation

Government provides some programs, funding, and infrastructure, but support is fragmented or bureaucratic

Government is a strategic enabler through proactive policy, funding, infrastructure, procurement and regulation

Government plans proactively,  systematically removes bottlenecks and coordinates the ecosystem, while allowing innovation to emerge bottom-up

Industry Bodies/ Incubators (IB)

Actors are largely disconnected; little matchmaking, mentoring or technology transfer

Some associations, incubators, accelerators and other intermediaries exist, but connections are uneven. Incubators are weak/missing for deep-tech

Effective facilitation of knowledge, talent, finance and market access among government ↔ research ↔ startups ↔ investors ↔ established firms. Connections remain dense for a few regional hubs. Rest weak.

Dense, high-quality connective tissue continuously creates valuable connections and substantially lowers information/transaction costs across the ecosystem

Established Firms (EF)

Firms mostly imitate or resist; little technology adoption, R&D or experimentation

Technology adopters: firms broadly deploy technologies developed elsewhere

Technology absorbers & developers: firms systematically absorb, adapt and improve external technologies, with meaningful proprietary R&D

Technology creators & platform builders: firms repeatedly develop frontier technology and build reusable technological/organizational platforms, influencing technological trajectories

Startups (S)

Few startups; weak entrepreneurial capability and experimentation

Growing startup population, but concentrated in a few sectors and dependent on external technology/capital

Strong pipeline of startups able to experiment, develop products, attract capital and scale across multiple sectors

Continuous creation and scaling of globally significant, technology-intensive companies and new industries

Educational & Research institutes (ERI)

Weak research base; limited relevant talent and little industry connection

Pockets of research excellence, but fragmented and weakly connected to commercialization

Strong universities/research institutes producing relevant talent and knowledge, with meaningful industry/startup links

World-class research continuously generates frontier knowledge, talent and technologies, with exceptionally strong research → technology → startup/firm → market conversion

Investors (I)

Very limited risk capital; major financing gaps

Functioning VC/angel market, but concentrated on proven/short-cycle opportunities; deep tech difficult to finance

Significant specialized capital across seed-to-growth, including patient capital for high-risk/deep-tech innovation

Exceptionally deep, competitive and globally connected capital ecosystem that routinely finances frontier technology from lab/seed through global scale

 



Innovation ecosystem India, China & Silicon Valley: This is how the dashboard looks for India-2007 (original graph modified with an additional dimension), India-2026, China-2026, and Silicon Valley. For Silicon Valley, actually, the incubator/accelerator dimension got strengthened further, with a couple of dozen new accelerators established. But for our purposes, we have assumed it to be the benchmark and not changed significantly.

Assumptions behind the ratings:

India 2007 rating: Assumptions are kept the same as those presented in NB2007. All dimensions are rated 1.5 except the investors dimension, which is rated 1.
  1. The government had a DST budget, but there was no focused effort in commercializing the science and technology. Most departments operated in silos. National Innovation Mission was established 3 years later in 2010. (rating: 1.5)
  2. Industry bodies existed for some sectors like IT, automotive, pharma, and consumer electronics but didn’t exist for sectors like medical devices, robotics, and space tech. Moreover, there were very few incubators in the country. (rating: 1.5)
  3. Very few startups, especially in emerging sectors like e-commerce. MakeMyTrip, Naukri.com, Shaadi.com, a few companies creating IP in telecom and multimedia like Ittiam, Tejas, Sasken, etc.
  4. There were a few established firms like Tata Motors, Mahindra, Titan,
  5. Indian startups got $0.5B in venture capital in 2007. In contrast, Silicon Valley startups got $11B, and Chinese startups got $3.8B in the same year. (rating: 1)

India 2026 rating:

  1. Government (rating change 1.5 to 2.5): The Indian government has developed a more ambitious and sophisticated set of innovation-policy instruments since 2007. For example, India Semiconductor Mission (ISM) (launched: December 2021, ₹76,000 crore), National Quantum Mission (NQM) (launched April 2023, ₹6,000 crore), and IndiaAI Mission (March 2024, ₹10,000 crore) [2]. The government has demonstrated sustained effort in developing digital public infrastructure (DPI)[3]. However, there are still significant gaps between policy announcements, resource deployment, and technological outcomes—and limited evidence of anticipatory preparedness. All of these missions were announced after the crisis was evident or after the US and China demonstrated significant milestones. The government’s R&D expenditure has increased substantially since 2007, but as a percentage of GDP it remained roughly the same, below 1%. Most of these programs are too recent, and their actual expenditure remains significantly below the projected budget for the duration of their life so far. For example, for the Semicon India Program (SMI), expenditure in the first two years,      FY23-24 and FY24-25, was 23% and 5% of the Budget estimate, respectively [4]. For IndiaAI Mission, the expenditure in FY24-25 and FY25-26 is at 3.5% and 13% respectively of the allocated budget [5].
  1. Startups (rating change from 1.5 to 3): In FY26, India recognized 55,200 startups as opposed to 36,400 in FY25 [6]. Some of them have scaled well in the last two decades, like Flipkart, Zerodha, and Ather Energy. However, most of them are software-heavy, asset-light, with the exception of Ather. The positive side is that many have come up before policy push was established. India’s startup ecosystem is still weak in deep-tech and manufacturing sectors. We have startups in space tech, defense, healthcare, and semiconductors, but most of them are in the early stages of the lifecycle.
  1. Established Firms (rating change from 1.5 to 2.5): India’s R&D expenditure itself is below 1% of GDP and within that, the contribution of established firms is around 30%. In contrast, the private sector contributes more than 60% of R&D in the US. This is also reflected in the annual reports of listed companies. Pharma companies like Dr Reddy’s, Sun Pharma (~8% of Revenue), Tata Motors (5%), Mahindra (~4%), HAL (~9%), and BEL (6%)  are some of the top R&D spenders, with 20 of the 1000 listed companies accounting for 70% of the R&D expenditure [6]. That is how concentrated it is. Firms like Amara Raja Energy and Mobility (batteries) and Poly Medicure (medical devices) are making a conscious effort to move up the value chain in the last few years. But most of the established firms remain efficiency-focused.
  1. Investors (rating change from 1 to 2.5): India attracted $60B private-equity and venture-capital investment in 2025 across 1475 deals according to EY-IVCA report [8]. Indian deep-tech funds companies raised ~$3B in 2025 across 189 deals. Deep tech’s share of PE-VC activity increased from 4% to 15% in 2025. However, capital remains concentrated in selected sectors.
  1. Industry Bodies and Incubators (rating change from 1.5 to 2.5): According to the IIT Madras CREST Research 2024 [9], India has 1,100 incubators. In 2007, there were around 100 incubators. So the number of incubators has increased significantly. However, current incubator density in India is 0.8 incubators per million population compared with 8-10 in the US, UK, and China. Moreover, 45% of them are in southern India, and Tier-1 cities account for 48% of incubators. So these are geographically concentrated in a few cities. Effectiveness of the incubators, especially in establishing ecosystem connectivity i.e., connecting research institutions, startups, established firms, and investors, remains questionable. It is likely to be low for most incubators.
  1. Education and Research Institutes (rating change from 1.5 to 2.5): Number of researchers in Indian education and research institutes has increased from around 100 in 2000 to 350 in 2025 [10]. In contrast, China had approximately 1500 researchers per million in 2020. India has developed centres of excellence such as the IISER network, IIT Hyderabad, IIT Madras Research Park, NCBS, and Technology Innovation Hubs (TIHs). However, university-industry collaboration and translational research remain weak in India. For example, between 2021 and 2023, there were 1,839 technology transfers by 233 public R&D institutions. In contrast, there were 661,000 contracts worth $34B from 4000 universities in 2024 in China [11].
To summarize, India's innovation ecosystem has improved significantly in the last two decades. However, there are significant gaps in the government’s strategic and proactive policymaking and execution, deep-tech technology incubation and investments, R&D contribution from established firms, ecosystem connectivity from incubators/industry bodies, and translational research in education and research institutes.  

AI assistance disclosure: This article was developed with assistance from OpenAI's ChatGPT, powered by the GPT-6 model family (accessed from August 12 to October 30, 2026). The author is responsible for the final content, interpretation, and conclusions.

Sources:

1. NASSCOM_BCG Innovationreport 2007

2. Parliamentary Question: Artificial Intelligence, research and innovation, Ministry of Science and Technology, Press Information Bureau, Government of India, August 12, 2026

3. India’s Digital Public Infrastructure, Setting a global benchmark for population-scale DPI, March 6, 2026

4. Union Budget 2026-27, Analysis of Expenditures by Ministries, PRS India, March 2026

5. Parliamentary panel flags delays and underutilization of funds in AI, chip schemes, Sejal Sharma, Hindustan Times, March 16, 2026.

6. Government recognizes more than 55,200 startups during FY 2025-26, highest ever in a single year since launch of Startup India initiative, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, April 17, 2026

7. India Inc failed to ramp up R&D spends despite ‘90s economic reform push, Krishna Kant, September 22, 2026

8. India’s PE/VC industry staying on the front foot despite global headwinds: EY-IVCA Trendbook 2026, March 10, 2026

9. India incubatorkaleidoscope 2024, democratizing entrepreneurial dreams, Srivardhini Jha and Thillai Rajan A, Centre for Research on Start-ups and Risk Financing (CREST),2024

10. Research and Development statistics at a glance, Department of Science and Technology, July 2026

11. China reports robust sci-tech transformation, September 22, 2025

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Role of mindfulness in the journey from confusion to clarity

“My job is boring; how do I find my passion or calling?” “What if AI takes over my job?” “How do I decide whether I spend the rest of my life with this person?” “Why am I staying away from my family in this city?” Questions like these come, stay for a while, get resolved, or sometimes lose their significance. Life moves on. Being confused is normal. However, sometimes it creates a cloud that refuses to go away. It can create repetitive thought patterns that consume excessive energy. What kinds of confusion do we have? And how does mindfulness help with the journey from confusion to clarity? Let’s explore this in this article.

I feel that confusions that tend to linger are associated with these three questions: Who am I? What do my relationships mean to me? And, how to make a living? The first question relates to my social, religious, political, gender, and caste identity; the second relates to my relationships with people and the planet; and the third pertains to balancing time between work and non-work activities and achieving professional and personal goals. 

Each of us iterates through a sensing-solving loop mostly without our awareness. If I am confused about a relationship, I run various scenarios in my mind and, through my actions, try to improve the relationship.  Confusion persists, perhaps because despite my efforts, the nature of the relationship doesn't improve. Or, there is decision paralysis leading to inaction or lack of communication and listening. A similar thing could happen in career stagnation. You apply outside, no response, boss is agitated, job drags on, etc. 

Mindfulness is based on the premise that the sensing-solving loop spends disproportionately more time in solving than sensing. That usually means beliefs underlying the problem definitions remain steadfast. Mindfulness suggests that the first step is to learn to spend time in the sensing mode. What is going on at this moment, outside and inside? Build attentional freedom to watch themovement of thought. What problem is it trying to solve? Is it going around in circles? 

Sometimes clarity emerges suddenly when a belief held tightly over a long period gets relaxed. Why do I have to be working all the time? Can I take a break, travel to some new places, meet some old friends, learn new skills, and then see what I want to do next? Sometimes clarity emerges slowly, by making small changes to one’s life. I can go to an overnight sky observation camp or to a weekend hike or to a short silent retreat. And then realize that perhaps I can do this more often. This is called “scaling the internal bright spots”: do more of what is working already. 

Is mindfulness necessary for clarity to emerge? No. Clarity can emerge any time, suddenly, in the most unlikely places, like during a meeting with the boss. Sometimes a boss’s remark can push one into the sensing mode. In the film, “The Devil Wears Prada,” boss Miranda (Meryl Streep) tells her personal assistant Andrea (Anne Hathaway), “I see a great deal of myself in you.” This comes as a shock to Andy, who believes her boss is evil, and then sees a shade of truth in what her boss is saying. That’s when leaving the toxic environment feels natural. 

Mindfulness nudges one to bring a balance between the sensing and the solving mode. For most of us, it usually means more sensing and less solving. With clarity, I learn to see the three characteristics clearly: impermanence (aniccha), unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), and no independent self (anatta). This clarity rebalances the significance I give to my beliefs and helps me connect with people and the planet with more openness.

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Insights from Martha Kessler on strategy analysis

My last job was that of a Strategy Analyst in a business unit during 2005-06. It didn’t take long to realize that my primary responsibility was to create a data-backed case justifying senior management decisions, a kind of reverse engineering. The leaders were privy to a much bigger context, travelled extensively meeting CXOs in client and partner organizations mostly abroad, and were aware of investor expectations.  In contrast, I was an armchair analyst synthesizing traffic from the meetings and the Internet. I didn’t know at the time that the “damn analyst”, as Henry Kissinger’s called him, in an intelligence department does pretty much the same, even if the decision involves going to war in Iraq to topple Saddam Hussein. What should a strategy analyst be careful about? In this article, I would like to summarize the 3 tips Martha Kessler gives in a panel on “1973 Arab-Israeli War: An intelligence analyst perspective” in 2013 (Martha's speech starts at 30:50)

Martha Kessler was in her mid-twenties when she was deputed as an analyst to the Office of Current Intelligence (OCI) in Libya and then moved in the Arab-Israeli Office branch after Libya merged with Egypt for a short time months before Arab-Israel Yom-Kippur war in 1973. In the panel, she describes 3 things she learned from her career in the CIA spanning four decades from 1970 to 2010.

For weeks leading up to the war that started on October 6, 1973, Martha was reading both the Libyan and Egyptian traffic. The Libya-Egypt country merger was a distraction for analysts as policy-makers were very much interested in it. Soviet Union had withdrawn its support for Egypt the year before (1972). A seven-page report came in from Cairo on its implications. It was a well-written, seemingly well-reasoned argument as to why Egypt was not going to go to war. It would have been extremely difficult for a Washington-based analyst to go against an opinion from the Chief of Station on the ground. When the war started, Martha got a call in the middle of the night. She and other US citizens were evacuated through Libya. The war was quite a shock to her, and its impact made Martha rethink her career because she realized a mistake of this sort could have huge consequences. What was she missing?

Context creates a filter: Years later, when Martha was deputed again as an Egyptian analyst, she reflected on her experience. She realized that she and many others were missing the context. The first aspect was that the legitimacy of the Sadat regime was disintegrating by the day. He was living with the legacy of the 1967 disaster. And he was running out of time. The Egyptian economy was under stress. They also had the burden of the Yemen war. The Egyptian population had been asked to sacrifice for a very long time. There was exhaustion in the military. There was humiliation in the eyes of the Arab world, and among Egypt’s supporters in Europe and the Non-Aligned world. The attitude of Israelis was extremely arrogant; they haunted the Egyptians. US and Soviets were negotiating cooperation agreements, and Sadat was the loser. Sadat had to do a begging bowl operation to survive militarily. Martha says, “If there had been this construct of context through which intelligence information had been filtered, we would have had a much stronger case in our own minds about whether Sadat was going to go to war or not.” Perhaps a similar contextual filter was at play – that Hamas won’t attack Israel – fifty years later.

Deception as distraction:  There was a hostage crisis created by As-Sa’iqa, a Palestinian organization created and controlled by Syria. On September 28, 1973, members of As-Sa’iqa took Jewish emigrants from the Soviet Union hostage while they were traveling through Austria. Similarly, on October 4, Egypt announced demobilization of some reservists. There were a number of military exercises near the border. This was part of a broader deception effort. Martha says, “Deception, and this was very very good deception, is very hard to uncover.” Perhaps awareness of the fact that there could be deception is a good first step.

Role of biases and competing hypotheses: Martha highlighted tools like assumption checks and analysis of competing hypotheses. She says, “Think what it would have meant to be able to uncover our feelings that Israelis always win wars, Arabs always lose them. And we had a clearer idea of our biases and assumptions.” Another tool she highlighted was “analysis of competing hypotheses”. Keeping competing hypotheses alive and seeing how incoming information strengthens or weakens them. To me, it looks like a Bayesian belief update mechanism.

In my case, after six months into the job, tracking various assumptions behind the business plan and validating them with the internal and external data, I concluded that the business was not going anywhere. Of course, nobody believed me. It was one of the triggers for me to leave. It took a couple of years before the decline started reflecting in the annual reports, and the business unit was eventually disbanded.  

On March 26, 2003, six days after Bush announced the invasion of Iraq, Martha Kessler gave a public speech at the University of Delaware titled “Intrigue of the Mideast Bazaar”. She said, “There may not even be an Iraq after the war because there is a real danger that the region could descend into chaos. Reconstruction may take considerably longer.” When asked how long it would take to establish democracy in Iraq, she said, “Perhaps never.” Damned analysts sometimes see things clearly.

image source: youtube.com

Saturday, October 3, 2026

Ford-Bezos vs Gandhi-Schumacher: Two paradigms of frugal innovation

This is the last slide from the “Frugal innovation” session I delivered last month to a cohort of executive MBA students from the University of Sidney at IIM Bangalore. I gave this talk for the first time at IIMB when a similar group from HEC Paris visited a decade ago, and I've taught it from time to time. This slide presents two dominant paradigms that enable frugal innovations that benefit masses, especially the bottom of the pyramid. For simplicity, I call the first paradigm “Ford-Bezos,” as these two entrepreneurs epitomize the creation of efficient large-scale production systems that made goods like cars and online shopping available at low cost to the masses. The second paradigm, which I call “Gandhi-Schumacher,” named after Mahatma Gandhi and Fritz Schumacher, is also concerned with making goods available at low cost but with appropriate technology where production is distributed, and the machine feels like an extension of the human body. One could call the former technology-centric frugal innovation and the latter human-centric affordable innovation. One question that often gets raised is: Is the Ford-Bezos paradigm the clear winner right now?

Ford-Bezos paradigm: Most of us are familiar with this paradigm. It is a response to the question, “How do we build a large-scale, efficient production and distribution system that offers goods and services to masses?” Centralized production and automation are at the heart of this paradigm. In India, Amazon claims to deliver to every serviceable pincode in the country. Since 2013, it has partnered with India Post, tapping into more than 150,000 post offices in towns and villages with no other reliable courier coverage. By 2024, it was using 120 trains operating 130 intercity routes connecting 91 cities. Amazon globally employs 1 million robots in its warehouses (as of mid-2025) and 1.56 million people. Workers at warehouses across the US, UK, and India have complained about restrictive bathroom policies. As articulated in books like “Amazon Unbound: Jeff Bezos and the invention of Global Empire”, employee/worker-friendliness is not what Amazon is known for. Thus, the paradigm delivers low-cost goods but comes at a cost.

Gandhi-Schumacher paradigm: While Gandhiji is often considered the “father” of a movement later called “Appropriate technology”, Fritz Schumacher, the author of “Small is beautiful”, is considered its founder. In 1955, following a stint as an economic advisor to the government of Burma (now Myanmar), Schumacher published a short paper, “Economics in a Buddhist country”. A revised version was later published as "Buddhist economics" in 1965. In addition to Buddhism, Schumacher credited his ideas to Gandhi. 

Appropriate technology involves technological choice and application that is small-scale, affordable by its users, labour-intensive, energy-efficient, environmentally sustainable, and locally autonomous. By 1980, the number of organizations involved in development and promotion of appropriate technology had grown to 1000 worldwide. However, in 2010 Paul Polak announced, “The appropriate technology movement died peacefully in its sleep ten years ago.” The title of the essay is, “The death of appropriate technology, if you can’t sell it, don’t do it”. Of course, ideas don’t die easily. So, let’s look at a couple of organizations exhibiting this paradigm in India today.

Selco and Aravind Eye Care: Selco was started in 1995 by Harish Hande to create inclusive, adaptable, and enduring solar solutions. In its labs in Kalahandi in Odisha, Williamnagar in Meghalaya, Guwahati, and Bangalore, cross-functional teams that include an architect, a doctor, an engineer, a finance person, and sometimes an anthropologist and a Yakshagana artist meet to design new programs that address the question, “Is the energy solution affordable in the long run?” For example, a solar-powered sewing machine may enable a woman to produce 8 shirts a day instead of 2. However, if she is not able to find a market for her products, then there is a danger of creating technology debt, says Hande. Hence, financing, maintenance, and support are important parts of solutioning. In the past few years, Selco revenue ranged between ₹90 and ₹140 crore (USD 10- 15 M), and it has been mostly profitable and self-sustaining.

Dr. Venkataswamy, the founder of Aravind, had a vision of making eye-care delivery as efficient as McDonald’s. When it started as an 11-bed hospital in 1976, five beds were for the paying patients, and six beds were for non-paying. FY24 activity report of Aravind says that out of a total of 729,187 surgeries, 363,330 (50%)were in the paying section, 250,349 were in the subsidised section with walk-ins to the free hospital, and 115,508 were done through free camps organized by its seven hospitals. In FY24, Aurolab launched 7 new surgical products, doctors at Aravind published 180 papers, and a conference for Mid-Level Ophthalmic Personnel (MLOP) and admin staff had 319 submissions, 200 presentations, and 55 participants winning prizes. When Aravind celebrated its golden jubilee last month, my guess is that the original question Dr V asked, “How to eliminate needless blindness?” was raised again.

Aravind seems to combine the scale and efficiency of the Ford-Bezos paradigm with the compassion and empowerment of the Gandhi-Schumacher paradigm. Aravind is a not-for-profit organization and is still run by a set of dedicated people groomed by Dr V.

Fortune at the bottom of the pyramid? When C K Prahalad wrote the book “The fortune at the bottom of the pyramid: Eradicate poverty through profits” in 2004, Aravind figured prominently in it. Within a couple of years, Prahalad’s colleague Aneel Karnani, at the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business, wrote a rebuttal, “Fortune at the bottom of the pyramid: A mirage”. Karnani argued that the BoP market is generally too small monetarily to be profitable for most multinationals. What is the verdict after two decades?

Large multinational FMCG companies like Hindustan Unilever, Nestle, and Colgate have been serving rural India for half a century. And now Amazon is taking it to the next level. And yet, Blume Ventures, an early-stage venture fund headquartered in Mumbai, puts it bluntly in the following slide from their Indus Valley Annual Report (2025). It calls India-3 the market with the bottom 1 billion people unmonetizable. Perhaps it is saying that unless you are selling soap, shampoo, toothpaste, noodles, and cigarettes, don’t bother selling to BoP.


Gandhi’s talisman test: Gandhi left the following quote in 1948, which was published posthumously. "I will give you a talisman. Whenever you are in doubt, or when the self becomes too much with you, apply the following test. Recall the face of the poorest and the weakest man [woman] whom you may have seen, and ask yourself, if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him [her]. Will he [she] gain anything by it? Will it restore him [her] to a control over his [her] own life and destiny? In other words, will it lead to swaraj [freedom] for the hungry and spiritually starving millions? Then you will find your doubts and your self melt away."

People like Dr V of Aravind and Harish Hande of Selco seem to be genuinely concerned with the BoP. They don’t start with the pursuit of making a lot of money for themselves. Without compassion, the Gandhi-Schumacher paradigm is a burden. This is where Gandhi’s talisman test – to check how big the self has become – turns relevant. Self-awareness puts “self” in its proper place in relation to other people and the planet. This dimension is sometimes referred to as the spiritual dimension. As Prof. Kasturi Rangan of Harvard Business School said of Dr V, “This man’s spirituality wasn’t incidental to the story. It was what everything else hinged on.”

To summarize, Ford-Bezos is the dominant paradigm worldwide today. It is playing an important role in making goods and services available to the masses at low cost. In many places, it is delivering at the expense of the environment and by undermining the human spirit. Unlike Paul Polak, I think the Gandhi-Schumacher paradigm isn’t dead. Actually, even Polak pointed out in his essay that “new movements for the design of technology for the poor are emerging from the ashes.”  He referred to Design for Extreme Affordability at Stanford and D-Lab at MIT. In fact, due to shifting institutional priorities, the Stanford program is closing this Fall (2026). In India, IIT Bombay’s Tata Centre for Technology and Design and IIT Madras’s Rural Technology Action Group (RuTAG) are active in this area. And Polak is right: marketing and selling are an integral part of the sustainability of the model. Moreover, like Harish Hande, it is important to ask, “Is this solution affordable in the long run?” So long as there are people who see themselves as deeply connected with other people and the planet, the Gandhi-Schumacher paradigm will persist.